Review: QuickTime Player X

For those upgrading to Snow Leopard, Apple's most recent enhancement to its core operating system, the look-and-feel updates to applications such as the QuickTime Player X are a welcome addition.

As mentioned in an article I'd written for StreamingMedia.com,  QuickTime Player X eliminates borders and windows around the actual video playback, and embeds the controls directly in to the lower quarter of the video playback window. Look familiar? It's based on the iPhone's video playback window.

Even more than just the updated look, though, QuickTime Player X uses the best bits of iPhone video protocol handling. As I'd mentioned in another article, HTTP streaming and the ability to trim and share videos was available on the iPhone before it ever launched on the desktop player application.

Here, though, the good news ends. While QuickTime Player X integrates a few of the Pro features from its predecessor, QuickTime Player 7, it drops cuts-only editing altogether and dumbs down export to "save as" and "save for web" options - both of which have significantly reduced export capabilities.

Here is an example of a small portion of the export options in QuickTime Player 7:

Now here is the only set of export options in QuickTime Player X:

Significant difference!

Note that QuickTime Player 7 contained all the export options of QuickTime Player X (AppleTV, iPod / iPhone and computer), so this is not about Apple adding functionality. It's as if making a "pretty" product got in the way of making a functional product, at least when the previous product did so much more than the "new and improved" one.

To be completely fair, there is one more screen on QuickTime Player X: the Save for Web option. As the picture below shows, however, there aren't very many options (about half of what was available on a similar screen in QuickTime Player 7):

Even more disturbing, what's been left out of the exporting options on QuickTime Player X is anything that doesn't fit in Apple's direct sphere of influence: if you don't want to export to iPod, iPhone, AppleTV or a Mac, you're out of luck with QuickTime Player X.

It's as if Apple is foregoing QuickTime's promise and premise to work across the board with a variety of formats and output options, instead closing ranks around its own products at the expense of extensibility.

Fortunately, for those who upgrade to Snow Leopard (10.6) from the Leopard (10.5) operating system, Apple leave QuickTime Player 7 on the upgrade machine. Whether this is an oversight, or a nod to the fact that QuickTime X was shipped too early, the fact that QuickTime Player 7 is still functional is welcome news.


In summary, we applaud Apple's attempt to simplify a part of the export process for the average user, but not at the expense of the power user who found the earlier versions of QuickTime to be quite powerful workflow enhancers. We would at least expect QuickTime Player X to have a simplified "Share" section and a more robust "Export" section, even if the latter were hidden a level down below the basic export options.

Instead, what we get is a very crippled version of an older system that worked quite nicely. So much for progress!



[Tested on 10.6.1 with QuickTime Player 7 version 7.6.3 (build 630) and QuickTime Player X version 10.0 (build 51)]